Verlaine Wright, long time historian of the cemetery wrote this about the cemetery's history:
"There were only three people buried on the hillside in the early years because the hill was on private land. It was not until 1882 that John V. Johnson deeded a 2-acre parcel of his land to Miller Station for use as a cemetery."
In 1919, with the annexation of Miller by the City of Gary, the cemetery became property of the City. In 1965 the church successfully petitioned the city to give it back to Bethel Lutheran. Unfortunately, there was never a register of burials; inventories were done by examining headstones, often broken or vandalized. A chapter of the D.A.R. did an inventory in 1957. The church's Cemetery Association did a map and inventory in 1976; the Northwest Indiana Genealogical Society compiled an inventory in 1999. With the advent of Find-a-Grave, it became possible for anyone to add memorials to the cemetery.
A more complete history can be read or downloaded here. While not dated or signed it is likely the work of Verlaine Wright.(Retrieved from the Calumet Archives)
Many people are buried in unmarked graves. These vary from previously unnamed explosion victims to people who died in Miller, sometimes vagrants, or, the chap who was found in the lagoon in 1908, never identified or cause of death determined; while there is really no evidence he is buried in the cemetery, it seems likely. It was in researching obituaries in the newspapers that I came across stories of unnamed individuals found along side the tracks. I've not collected those, but have discovered the names of 28 victims of 12 deadly explosions at the Aetna Powder Plant, 12 of whom are very definitely buried in the cemetery and 2 who are very likely buried there.
Much more detail about the explosions and their victims are on the Explosion History page and at a Find-a-Grave "Virtual Cemetery". It can be found here at
Inventories, including the latest one created by me are on another page.
New page created November, 2018. Updated April, 2020.
Feel free to contact me about this page.